Well we still have bow doors on ferries so not sure what your point on that is and I'm not sure where the Bradford fire fits into all this?. My point is that swinging doors on 1000s of carriages in daily use , mainly the southern, with people desperate to get off at say Waterloo and head for the City line is a different beast to what we have now, the 2005 report into this is now largely irrelevant in my opinion. WCR running on the line to Mallaig is as benign as you can get in all of this , sick of the overreactions to all this to be honest, wonder how some people on here manage to leave their bedrooms to be honest. If WCR were to stopped from running it should of been the TPWS incident in my opinion, this whole episode leading to the devastating effect on the tourism in that area is a joke, in my humble opinion.